First Industrial Realty Trust Inc. (FR)
First Industrial Realty Trust is a Real Estate Investment Trust. They buy, manage, develop and sell commercial real estate.
As you know from my earlier blogs, I’m searching for valuable investments on today’s stock market. (Yes, really)
My ‘buy’ order went in October 13 for First Industrial Realty when the price was $16.25. This was a good price relative to the value shown on the second quarter financial statements, the most recent available at the time.
Today the price is $10.34. I liked the stock at $16.25, and I really like it at ten bucks
Why is this stock dropping?
In general, it seems that everything on the stock market is dropping. Moreover, the Credit Crisis will certainly impact FR’s ability to operate, and FR will have to change their strategy to adapt. In the second half of 2007, the stock was trading between $32 and $39 before the Credit Crisis. The earlier price reflected the value of the existing business (the portfolio of existing income earning properties) and the potential for growth. The Credit Crisis will impact management’s ability to finance new deals. So in the current environment, if management will not be able to deliver the capital gains from buying and selling properties, it makes sense for the stock price to come down.
OK, fine. Future growth prospects for the Company will be lower. But the Company still has the value of the existing portfolio of properties. Has the stock been ‘over sold’? Did the price come down too much?
Let’s compare the price of the stock to the value of the Company as reflected in the financial statements.
First, let’s take the Balance Sheet.
Balance Sheet
At $10 per share (the November 3 price), the Company is valued at $443 million. If you buy the Company, (or a share of the Company), what do you get?
Since First Industrial Realty Trust is a Real Estate Investment Trust, when you buy the Company (or a share), you are doing a commercial real estate deal. I’ve simplified and rearranged the Balance Sheet so it will be easier to identify the values on the Balance Sheet.
The June 30, 2008 Balance Sheet shows $2,727 million Property and $1,962 million Debt. ‘Net Real Estate’ (Property minus Debt) is $765 million.
And you bought it for $443 million. (“.58 cents on the $ dollar”)
You get ‘the rest of the Company’ -- $348 million – for “free.” The ‘rest of the company’ is ‘All Other Assets’ of $564 million, less ‘All Other Liabilities’ $216 million.
For this discussion, I’ve just rearranged the Balance Sheet and summarized it like this:
- ‘Net Real Estate’ (Total Property minus Debt), $765 million; plus
- ‘The rest of the business,’ $348 million; less
- Minority Interest, $151 million; gives you
- Balance Sheet Equity, $962 million.
Or think about this on a ‘per share’ basis.
Buy the stock at $10 per share, and get
- ‘Net Real Estate’ (Property minus Debt), $17.27 per share; plus
- “The rest of the business” of $7.85 per share; less
- Minority Interest, $3.41 per share; gives you
- Balance Sheet Equity, $21.71 per share.
Now, let’s take the Income Statement.
Income Statement
Here is another way to think of this investment decision as a commercial real estate deal
Let me use a few paragraphs to lay out some definitions. Stay with me; there will be a ‘pay off’ at the end.
Net Operating Income (“NOI”) defined
Real Estate investors use Net Operating Income as a measure of profitability, rather than Net Income. Generally, NOI is defined as Income (Earnings) before Depreciation and Interest Expenses:
Net Operating Income = Net income + depreciation + interest expense + income tax – repairs
Another way to think about this is that Net Operating Income is basically “Funds from Operations before interest expense and taxes”. It measures the property’s ability to generate ‘cash’ profits before financing costs.
Capitalization Rate (“Cap Rate”) defined
In commercial real estate, the Cap Rate is Net Operating Income divided by the Purchase Price of the investment.
Net Operating Income / Purchase Price = Capitalization Rate
For example, if an apartment building is purchased for $10 million and provides $1 million in Net Operating Income, then the Cap Rate is 10%. Every deal has a unique Cap Rate. Some factors that can vary the Cap Rate are:
The type of real estate (apartment, industrial, or office, etc.)
The general economic environment (interest rates, changing underwriting standards, etc.
In general, before the Credit Crisis, Cap Rates were coming down. Industrial real estate deals have seen the Cap Rates come down from about 10% at the beginning of the decade to about 7.5% in 2007, at the high point in the real estate value bubble.
Real estate investors will often use a given Cap Rate to determine the Purchase Price by algebraic manipulation of the equation above.
Purchase Price = Net Operating Income / Capitalization Rate
Purchasing an industrial real estate property with $1 million in Net Operating Income and a 10% Cap Rate would cost $10 million. Purchasing the same industrial real estate property with $1 million Net Operating Income and a 7.5% Cap Rate would cost $13.3 million.
Let’s get back to First Industrial Realty.
FR’s Cap Rates
For the Nine months ending September 31, 2008, First Industrial Realty bought property at an average Cap Rate of 8.2% and put property in service at an average Cap Rate of 9.0%.
Now, let’s perform an analogous calculation on the whole Company (not just an individual property.)
FR’s Income
Based on management’s guidance on 2008 Funds from Operations (FFO), I estimate FR’s 2008 NOI will be about $4.25 per share. Based on management’s 2009 FFO guidance, I estimate the Company’s 2009 NOI will be about $4.15. (For both projections, I had to estimate interest expense, taxes and capital expenditures for repairs.)
FR’s Cap Rate, today
With NOI per share of about $4.15, when the stock is trading at $10 per share, the Cap Rate is 41.5%. You can buy about $4.15 of Operating Income for only about $10 per share.
This is a commercial real estate deal. Can you drive around Dallas or LA or Miami and buy commercial real estate for a Cap Rate of 41.5%?
When FR management buys property and puts it in service, they earn a Cap Rate of about 9.0%, which is pretty good.
But we can do better. We can buy First Realty Industrial itself at a Cap Rate of 41.5%. This is like someone handing us a packaged and diversified real estate deal.
Next Steps
In future blogs, I outline other topics such as:
FR’s ability to service their debt
FR’s FFO
The Q3 financial statements
Other metrics of value, such as a ‘P-E” ratio.
Conclusion
But for now, keep this in mind.
When you are buying FR at $10, you are getting the Net Real Estate (Property net Debt) at ‘.58 cents on the $ dollar” and the rest of the Balance Sheet gets included at no extra cost.
These days you can get a better commercial real estate deal when you “buy the real estate” on Wall Street, rather than trying to get a good deal on Main Street.